Best Overall
Gear Doctors ApolloAir 5.2
Key details
- Weight
- 22 oz
- R-value
- 5.2
- Inflation
- Pump sack
- Inflated Size
- 72.1 x 22 x 3.25 in
A 5.2 R-value in a pad that weighs 22 ounces is the figure that settled this guide. Warmth is the one thing you cannot add to a sleeping pad later — you can lay a jacket over a cold pad, but you cannot insulate it — and the ApolloAir is the only pad here rated for four-season use. Whatever Gear Doctors put inside it does not cost packed size: 8.5 inches tall and about 3 inches across, roughly a large water bottle.
The pump sack is the part we did not expect to like. It looks fussy, but it fills the pad with trapped air in a handful of scoops and never leaves you lightheaded at the end of a long day, which is more than we can say for blowing up a 3-inch pad by mouth. The valve seats cleanly and dumps the air fast when you are packing up in the rain, and the 3.25-inch chamber is deep enough that a hip does not reach the ground.
What you give up is width and headroom on the weight limit. At 22 inches it is on the narrow side for this group, and 250 pounds is the lowest limit stated here, so bigger sleepers should look at the FUN PAC or the Hikenture. If you sleep on your back and do not thrash, neither matters. If you roll from hip to hip all night, the extra inches elsewhere will buy you more sleep than the R-value will.
Pros
- Warmest pad here at R-5.2
- 22 oz and packs to bottle size
- 3.25 inches cushions side sleepers
- Pump sack inflates without dizziness
Cons
- 22-inch width feels narrow to bigger sleepers
- 250 lb limit is the lowest here
If you want one pad for cold mornings and long carries, this is the one we hand people: the warmest and most packable here.