Best Overall
Marmot PreCip Eco
Key details
- Hood
- Attached, adjustable
- Pockets
- 2 zippered
- Material
- 100% recycled nylon
- Listed Weight
- 7.05 oz
Two zips under the arms are what put the PreCip Eco at the top of this list. A waterproof shell that can't vent turns into a sauna the moment the trail tilts upward, and these let you dump heat without stopping to peel the jacket off. The fabric is recycled nylon with a PFC-free finish, the hood adjusts properly, and the listed weight is 0.2 kg — about seven ounces. That last figure is the one that decides whether a shell rides in your pack or stays in the closet.
The details are where it pulls ahead of the cheaper shells here. The hood rolls down and stows in the collar, so it stops flapping at your neck when the rain eases, and the chin guard is lined, which you appreciate on a long day with the zip all the way up. The two zippered hand pockets sit clear of a pack's hipbelt. Ours came out of the washing machine ready to go again, which matters for something that lives in a stuff sack.
The caveat is longevity at the lining. After several seasons of hard use the inner coating can start to flake, which turns a jacket that still looks fine on the outside into one that sheds on your shirt. Treat the PreCip as a shell you replace every few years rather than a hand-me-down, and the arithmetic still works. The cut is regular, with room for a light fleece and not much more.
Pros
- Underarm zips dump heat on a climb
- Recycled nylon with a PFC-free finish
- Hood rolls down into the collar
- Listed at about seven ounces
Cons
- Inner lining can flake after seasons of use
Our top pick: the underarm zips make a waterproof shell wearable on a climb, and it's the lightest of these on paper.