Best Overall
Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Glove
Key details
- Cuff
- Knit cuff
- Weight
- 7.2 oz
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof shell
The knit cuff is the detail that sold us. It slides up under a jacket sleeve and closes the gap where cold air gets in, and unlike a long gauntlet it does not bunch up inside a coat you are already wearing. Add the waterproof insulated build and you have the glove we recommend first to anyone who spends real time outdoors in winter — shoveling, splitting wood, walking the dog through sleet. At 7.2 ounces it feels like a work glove rather than a fashion glove, and that is the point.
Warmth is the headline. Fingers stay comfortable through a long stint outside, and the palms hold a shovel handle or a ladder rung without the slickness of a cheap knit. What we kept noticing is what happens when they get properly wet: the shell keeps slush out in normal use, but once they are soaked through they take a while to dry, and the liner can pull out when you tug a wet hand free. Pull the liner, dry both pieces separately, and they are ready the next morning.
These are the warmest gloves in this group for wet, working cold, and they are the least interested in being convenient. They are bulky enough that buckling a helmet strap or fishing a coin out of a pocket takes two tries, and the knit cuff collects sawdust and burrs. If your winter is mostly the walk from a parking lot to a door, one of our lighter picks will feel better on your hands.
Pros
- Waterproof insulated build for wet, cold work
- Knit cuff seals the gap at the sleeve
- Holds warmth through long outdoor stints
- Tough palm stands up to shovel and ladder work
Cons
- Runs small; size up if between sizes
- No touchscreen fingertips
We recommend this pair first to anyone who spends real time outside in winter: it is warm, waterproof, and built to work, provided you size up.