Best Overall
Camco Portable Toilet Bucket
Key details
- Weight
- 4.7 lb
- Seat Height
- 16.1 inches
- Bucket Capacity
- 5 gallons
- Liners Included
- 3
There's no mechanism here, and that's the point: a five-gallon polypropylene bucket, a seat and lid that snap onto the rim, three liners in the box, and a molded handle. What makes it the default is the absence of machinery — no pump, no valve, no seal to lose — and a seat that sits at 16.1 inches, close enough to a household toilet that the height never enters your head.
What we watched for on a campsite was the stuff that goes wrong with cheap bucket toilets: a seat that shifts when you sit down, a base that rocks on uneven ground, a lid that doesn't seal. The bucket is rigid enough that it doesn't flex when you sit, the rim holds the seat where you put it, and the lid presses down tight enough to keep the smell in until morning.
The smooth interior is the other thing we noticed. It rinses clean at a tap in a way a textured pail doesn't, which matters when you're doing it by headlamp. Every use needs a liner and, ideally, a scoop of absorbent gel, so the toilet is only as good as the supply you bring — buy a box of refills alongside the bucket rather than after the first trip.
Where it stops being the right answer is a campground with strict pack-out rules and no trash, or a camper who simply won't sit on a bucket. That's what the flush models below are for. Everyone else gets a toilet that sets up in one motion, needs no water, and doesn't care how cold the night gets.
Pros
- Rigid bucket that doesn't flex or tip
- 16.1-inch seat close to household height
- Smooth interior rinses clean quickly
- Three liners included to start
Cons
- Every use needs a liner and gel
- Lid can be stiff to pry off
This is the camping toilet we recommend to most people: a rigid five-gallon bucket, a seat at household height, three liners in the box, and no valve or pump to fail.