Best Overall
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II
Key details
- Department
- Men's
- Listed Weight
- 1.12 lb
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
Wet ground is where inexpensive hiking boots give themselves away, so it is the first thing we check. The Newton Ridge Plus II passed. Rain, wet grass, and the muddy edge of a trail left our feet dry, and the suede upper shed water instead of soaking it up and staying heavy for the rest of the walk. That alone, at a midrange price, is why it is the boot we name first for most people.
The rest of the package holds up. Columbia lists the pair at 1.12 pounds, and on the foot it reads like a trail shoe with a collar rather than a stiff mountain boot, which you notice most on the second half of a long day. Grip is sure on packed dirt, gravel, and slick roots, and it held on snow and icy patches where cheap rubber skates. The collar sits high enough to feel supportive without cutting in, and lacing is the ordinary, no-fuss kind.
One boundary is worth naming: the waterproofing stops at the collar. Water that crests the tongue on a real stream crossing gets in, as it does on every mid-cut boot here, so plan on rock-hopping rather than wading. Within that, this is the boot we pack for a week of mixed weather and mixed terrain, from a local loop to a day of cobblestones in a city.
Pros
- Keeps feet dry in rain and wet grass
- Light on the foot for a mid-cut boot
- Sure grip on dirt, gravel, and ice
- Wide sizes available
Cons
- Runs narrow in the standard width
The boot we recommend to most hikers: dry in wet weather, light on the foot, sure-footed on mixed ground, and available in wide sizes.